Perceived impact of the patent linkage system on pharmaceutical market from the viewpoint of the domestic manufacturers in South Korea

Abstract

Background: The United States requires a patent linkage system in other countries as part of free trade agree‑ ments. However, introducing a patent linkage system could be a signifcant barrier to the timely approval of generic drugs. This study aimed to evaluate the perceived impact of the patent linkage system in South Korea held by domestic manufacturers and analyze variations in evaluating the system according to the characteristics of domestic manufacturers. Methods: In 2020, we conducted a questionnaire survey of 39 domestic manufacturers. The survey consisted of perceptions of the system, factors afecting patent challenges, and the perceived impact of the system. A 5-point Likert scale was used to rate each item. Domestic manufacturers were categorized into three groups based on their experience of listing a patent and acquiring frst generic exclusivity. Results: More than half of the manufacturers surveyed had experience of listing a patent. The patent linkage system could protect the involved patents. However, manufacturers perceived that they could successfully challenge the validity of the involved patents and then obtained market approval for generic drugs. Manufacturers responded that market size, expectations for succeeding in litigation, and expectations for manufacturing the drug were the most relevant factors when they initiated patent challenges. Manufacturers reported that the system, in particular the frst generic exclusivity, enhanced the research and development capability of generic manufacturers, increased their domestic sales, and improved access to generic drugs. Conclusions: The perceived impact of the patent linkage system was limited to the domestic market and generic drugs. In narrowing the impact to the efects on the domestic industry, the system had positive impacts of the system on generic manufacturers. The frst generic drug exclusivity lies at the center of this positive perception. However, manufacturers perceived that the current system did not provide enough incentives for domestic manufacturers to be granted frst generic drug exclusivity through patent challenges.